Loading…
Pizza · Palmyra, PA
Bartolo's Pizza is a family-owned pizza shop and Italian restaurant on Campbelltown Road in Palmyra, PA — a well-established local favorite known for a distinctively sweet sauce you won't find at the chains.
Our take If you want a no-fuss dinner that'll satisfy the whole car, Palmyra is a short hop down Route 422 from Hershey and Bartolo's is worth the detour.
When we send people looking for a solid slice in Lebanon County, Bartolo's is usually the first name out of our mouths. It's the kind of place that's earned its reputation the old-fashioned way — consistent food, a family behind the counter who cares, and a sauce that regulars will drive past three other pizza places to get. The sweet-sauce pies are what most people come back for, and the subs hold their own too. It fits right in with the kind of unpretentious, quality-first spots we like to highlight in our local guide.
Bartolo's is a family operation that has been doing what it does on Campbelltown Road in Palmyra for many years — long enough that some customers grew up eating here and now bring their own kids. The menu covers the Italian-American standards: Neapolitan and Sicilian-style pizzas, pasta dishes, subs, and salads. What keeps people coming back is less about novelty and more about reliability — you know exactly what you're getting, and it's good every time.
A little context on what to expect when you pull in. Bartolo's runs as a budget-friendly counter-serve spot — you order at the counter and the pizza is made fresh to order rather than pulled pre-made, which is part of what keeps regulars coming back for that slightly-sweet house sauce. There's a small indoor dining area plus some outdoor seating, so it works for a quick family dinner, though a big group is better off planning around the limited room since reservations aren't taken. Heads up on access: the dining room is on the snug side and there's a step at the entrance with no ramp, so if anyone in your party needs step-free access, it's worth a quick call ahead. Parking nearby is easy.
As of our last check, Bartolo's runs Tuesday through Saturday, 11 AM to 9 PM, and is closed Sunday and Monday — the official Location & Hours page is the one to trust, since some third-party listings show stale daily hours. Confirm on their site or call ahead if you're going out of your way.
Bartolo's Pizza is in Palmyra, PA. The map shows both pins — Bartolo's Pizza and our shop in Grantville — so you can see exactly where it sits relative to us.
A sampling across the menu, not the full list — Bartolo's goes well beyond pizza into stromboli, subs, pasta, salads, and wings. Prices are approximate, third-party-sourced, and subject to change, so confirm current offerings and pricing on their site.
The sweet tomato sauce is the calling card — it's house-made and noticeably different from the standard pizza sauce you find elsewhere. Combined with a family-run atmosphere and consistent quality over many years, it's carved out a loyal following in Lebanon County.
Yes — the shop is set up for both eat-in and takeout, which is how Bartolo's describes itself. We haven't been able to confirm in-house delivery, so if you'd want it delivered, call ahead to ask what they currently offer.
Absolutely. It's a casual, welcoming neighborhood spot where families are the norm, not the exception. The menu has plenty of familiar options that work for picky eaters alongside more traditional Italian dishes for adults.
Yes — Bartolo's links an 'Order Online' option directly from its official site through the umpa-us.com ordering platform, so you can put in your order before you arrive and pick it up without the wait. The setup is built around eat-in and takeout pickup. If you're hoping for delivery to a hotel, call the shop to confirm — we'd treat it as pickup-focused based on current sources.
Go for the namesake Sicilian Bartolo Special — a loaded pie with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, and hamburger — and you'll meet that slightly-sweet house sauce people come back for. The strombolis are the other calling card: the Regular packs ham, cheese, capicola, and sausage, and the Special piles on even more with onions, mushrooms, green peppers, and pepperoni added in.
Palmyra is an easy little cluster to make an evening of — it's a short hop down Route 422 from Hershey, and Bartolo's sits within minutes of a few other spots we point visitors toward. Round out a pizza dinner with a dessert stop or a grown-up drink nearby.
A short hop away on N Railroad St — a proper sit-down Italian bistro for the nights you want a longer dinner instead of counter-serve pizza, with a strong gluten-free menu for mixed-diet families.
A family-run seasonal snowball and ice-cream stand minutes away — the natural warm-weather dessert stop after a pizza dinner.
A Palmyra craft brewery nearby — an easy grown-up stop if the adults want a beer to round out the visit.
Bowling Center & Old West Saloon · Palmyra, PA
Pizza · Grantville, PA
Pizza · Hummelstown, PA
Pizza · Hummelstown, PA
Indoor Ice Skating Rink · Annville, PA
Indoor Laser Tag & Family Entertainment Center · Annville, PA
Visiting the Hershey area and need a mechanic? NextGen AutoWorks is a family-owned shop in Grantville, about 12 minutes north — we handle auto repair, tires, and PA state inspections. Traveling and something went wrong? Here's what to do if you have car trouble near Hershey — or book an appointment.
Verified via: Bartolo's Pizza (official site) · Bartolo's Pizza — Tripadvisor · Bartolo's Pizza — Location & Hours (official) · Bartolo's Pizza menu — AllMenus · Bartolo's Pizza — Restaurantji (attributes)
Bartolo's Pizza is an independent local business we're featuring in our guide — we're not affiliated. Details are from the business and public sources and were accurate at the time of writing; please confirm current hours before visiting.