Loading…
- Home
- Appointment
- Customer Portal
- Search For Tires
- Specials
- Why Choose Us
- Services
- Additional Resources
Pizza · Palmyra, PA
Bartolo's Pizza is a family-owned pizza shop and Italian restaurant on Campbelltown Road in Palmyra, PA — a well-established local favorite known for a distinctively sweet sauce you won't find at the chains.
When we send people looking for a solid slice in Lebanon County, Bartolo's is usually the first name out of our mouths. It's the kind of place that's earned its reputation the old-fashioned way — consistent food, a family behind the counter who cares, and a sauce that regulars will drive past three other pizza places to get. The sweet-sauce pies are what most people come back for, and the subs hold their own too. It fits right in with the kind of unpretentious, quality-first spots we like to highlight in our local guide.
Bartolo's is a family operation that has been doing what it does on Campbelltown Road in Palmyra for many years — long enough that some customers grew up eating here and now bring their own kids. The menu covers the Italian-American standards: Neapolitan and Sicilian-style pizzas, pasta dishes, subs, and salads. What keeps people coming back is less about novelty and more about reliability — you know exactly what you're getting, and it's good every time.
Open Tuesday through Saturday, 11 am to 9 pm; closed Sunday and Monday. Hours confirmed as of our research — call ahead or check their site if you're going out of your way.
206 Campbelltown Rd, Palmyra, PA 17078
The sweet tomato sauce is the calling card — it's house-made and noticeably different from the standard pizza sauce you find elsewhere. Combined with a family-run atmosphere and consistent quality over many years, it's carved out a loyal following in Lebanon County.
Yes — takeout is available, and the restaurant has also offered delivery. Check their website or call ahead for current delivery range and hours, as those details can change.
Absolutely. It's a casual, welcoming neighborhood spot where families are the norm, not the exception. The menu has plenty of familiar options that work for picky eaters alongside more traditional Italian dishes for adults.
Bartolo's Pizza is an independent local business we're featuring in our guide — we're not affiliated. Details are from the business and public sources and were accurate at the time of writing; please confirm current hours before visiting.